Ulp. Copyrighted Titles Accidentally Going Full-View in Google Book Search?
July 3rd, 2009From a message posted by Chad at Coachwhip Publications, seems there’s a title, A Song for Satawal, by Kenneth Brower, that’s available to any and all from Google Book Search, ‘cuz of an 1817 copyright date.
Book overview
Full view - 1817 - 218 pages
Unfortunately, 1817 marks the start of Harper and Row; book itself was first published 1983, and copyrighted in all nations apart from North Korea and Bhutan. Letting the whole .pdf of this book be downloaded is, err, probably a no-no.
I’m going to register anger now. When searching GBS, you’ll find some of the later (#6-10) Fantomas translations by Allain and Souvestre in the system, but despite being PD, you can’t download them, for no apparent reason. But, despite the popularity, you wouldn’t want to drop $3-400 on the originals, and then be able to download them six months later. Explain that sort of write-off to the IRS particularly if the scan date shows as ‘06. Grumble…
No later Juve, but, this poor guy’s title is available. Way to go, Google.
When not drinking or sleeping off effects of same at the Chelsea, I attended GBS things at BEA, talking about orphan works and so forth, plus what might be covered in the settlement. I don’t recall anyone, even the staunchest GBS advocate from the Guild, signing off for full-view, free downloads of content, inadvertent or otherwise. Google was held to be infallible.
Speculating here, but at least part of what might make Google’s errors actionable without the settlement is their failure to properly explain how books are chosen and scanned (they’re calling it a trade secret, implying a process that employs dedicated, full-time, vested employees who eagerly face mundane task of scanning thousands of books, as opposed to say, college students who handle light industrial work via the wake ‘n bake, 4:20 break, and maybe some lighter tokes in-between.) Spiel works well until the reader spots a peculiar hand-signal in certain editions…
Note, as someone who proofs full-views texts on a regular basis: Google’s scans have gotten more consistent, particularly since Spring ‘08 at Harvard, but… that book was uploaded June ‘08 from Cal, and this hopefully isolated incident is in no way a confidence-inspiring miss.
Share This